“What the hell is up with that title?!” Yes, well it caught me off guard too and I’m the author. As has happened to me in the past however, I had an idea for a blog post that (in my mind) was very cut and dry. Then I reached out to a ton of very talented people who I was willing to bet paper money on would feel the same way I did, only to readjust my own thinking that was clearly just a pessimistic attitude. So if you don’t feel like reading this whole post, here’s the big spoiler: Muppet fan artists are the greatest human beings to ever walk the planet. Too bold? Okay, then read on.

If you know me or have read practically any post from this blog, you know I’m a big fan of Jim Henson. You’ll also know I draw a lot of Muppets, like a whole lot. So much so that there is a notable and huge difference in the amount of attention an illustration of Kermit the Frog gets over something like, say an illustration of a hotdog. Definitely not a good comparison but it’s really moot at this point. People love when I draw the Muppets, and care minimally when I draw anything else. Creatively it can feel stifling and push to create something absurd. That’s not just an opportunity to post a link to an old post, I’ve covered this purposely when I asked aloud “Why Did I Draw That?” and it inadvertently answers this question, I’d love if you checked it out.

So the hard line in the sand here is that while I do in fact love drawing the creative efforts of everyone involved with various Henson and Muppet adjacent projects, I have often felt obligated or at the very least pigeonholed into drawing them more than I normally would or even should. The basic retaliatory emotion that follows feeling pigeonholed is righteous indignation because the creative person in question feels like they can contribute more to the zeitgeist than what they are already expected to. Sure I appreciate the love and attention from that piece I did of Miss Piggy, but wouldn’t you guys also like to see this fun zombie kid? Or maybe these historical figures? Not so much? Ouch! My ego!

So with my personal gripes neatly arranged in a manila folder, I reached out to a bunch of other artists expecting to hear back nothing but, “Yeah! I feel that way as well!” only to feel the full ethos of Jim Henson personified that only true Muppet fans could deliver. I asked, “Do you ever feel pigeonholed to draw Muppets?” and here’s what these amazing people told me in response.

Toffe

I never feel pressured to only draw Muppets, it just happened to be the thing I want to draw most! But while it’s disheartening to see a personal art post flop in the Instagram algorithm, I always remember that 100–500 of my followers like this too! So I continue to draw and post whatever I want because someone out there likes everything I post. So I always keep that in mind.

Justin Piatt

If I post anything that's not Muppet related, it generally doesn't do well at all. That can include my own puppets. If I post anything with Uzzy, my main character, it gets zip. Other puppets do well, especially if I post a lot of pictures, but Muppet replicas and Muppet art seem to be the only things that really take off.

I'll give you an example—my last two posted drawings. One was the Muppets, one was [a commissioned] piece I did for the Girl Scouts. The Muppet drawing has 394 likes (and counting). The Girl Scout one, filled with cute little big eyed animals, has 55.
It does make me feel more obligated to draw Muppets. At the same time, I hate the impression that it gives. That I'm obsessed and that's all I think about. Because I have a lot of people who know me personally that follow me, and I don't want that to be all they know me for.

Danny Beckwith

I often feel that Muppet-based or inspired work is something that seems to get attention more often than not. If I fall down the chasing "likes" rabbit-hole/mindset, I will often come back to Muppets. But I don't really chase likes and have to remind myself that when I make Muppet art, it's sometimes for me. Perhaps I'll share it (I always do, lol) for others to enjoy. But I've recently realized that making art with Muppets should never be a chore or a contest. I only now do it when I have true inspiration or feel that the Muppets being including in my art matches my values but also the values of those characters and the theme of the piece.

Kenny Durkin

…If anyone tries to refer to me as strictly a “Muppet artist” I ignore it. When I post artwork I tend to rotate them. So I’ll post a Muppet thing and follow it up with something more caricature related, then I’ll do a Father of the Brood or something like that. I also do that to remind people that I’m not a one trick pony.

The time I did get pigeonholed was when I was doing Duck Dynasty stuff. I gained a lot of followers who thought that "redneck" artwork was all I did. I had to "break the cycle" by posting goofy monsters, or aliens, or Muppets probably, just to show them what ELSE I can do.

Noah Ginex

Noah has been doing a Drawing A Day primarily featuring the Muppets.

Yes. that's... what this whole year has been. There's at least two whole universes of original characters I have that I never draw any more. Not to mention an entire universe of other fandoms I'm into. I basically don't do any other art now, except commission work. In fact, several of the drawings this year have been birthday presents for people that I've only done because I needed t–shirt designs and stuff
I only pour “Drawing a Day” into the spaces around my normal life, so I'm often doing them quickly late at night. So really the thing that they're using up is sleep… or this morning… ha ha ha right now!

But to answer the question of do I mind, no I love it. My t–shirt sales have jumped a bunch too. The real trouble, honestly, is ideas. With rare exception I'm always fighting the clock on thinking of a new thing to do. That doesn’t make me seem like more of a crazy person than I know I already come off as, drawing the same frog and bear and pig every day.

Jonathan Brangwynne

I’m pretty self-conscious of how much fan art I do vs. original stuff. I think most online artists feel pressured into doing fan art so they can be seen, and it is pretty frustrating. I do maintain that any original work that you create is part of your identity, and whether you think it’s good or bad, you should still keep at it and try to mix it up. Ultimately, you’re doing it for yourself, if no one else, and you’ll be able to show more range in your art and have a diverse portfolio.

Nick Bondra

I kinda got pigeonholed on other subject matter I did years ago but I think that’s subsided now. It does kinda’ sting when I draw something more of my own creation instead of fan art and don’t get much response. Heck, people mostly react to my Gobo Fraggle photo poser pics.
So, I do know where you’re coming from. I guess it just depends on how you feel about it. I’d only do it if it’s still fun for you.

Dan Romens

It's my general lack of frequency that tends to cause the disproportion, as it pulls me out of the algorithm. At least that's my theory. In other feeds or accounts, when I was more frequent, I felt like I got more engagement on my random or original work.

In terms of the Muppets specifically, for as long as I remember, the Henson characters have always been my go–to subjects in moments of art block. They are familiar and drawing them or original characters inspired by them comes easy. So I don't mind in that regard. I also love the Muppet fan art community.

I think where pigeonholing comes into play may have more to do with fan art in general. Regardless of the platform, fan art has always gotten the most engagement, which makes total sense, but can also feel limiting or like I need to pander to some niche audience in order to be seen or acknowledged. Draw a great cartoon dog? Nothing. Draw a cartoon dog dressed as Doctor Who or some such thing, gang busters. Again, it makes sense, but c'mon guys.

Quentin Tracy

As an artist, I have never felt tied to the Muppets. I’m a big fan of them, and they have inspired me many times, but they’re only one of many inspirations of mine. On a more broad scale, I feel like fan art in general guarantees me a good reception from my fans. That fact has left me a little discouraged to work on original ideas of mine, in fear that I may pour my heart and soul into something not many other people will think much about or care for.

Mike Boon

I can put a bunch of work into a new design and get some likes/comments. But then I post an old Muppet one and it's about three times as popular with a faster response. I don't take it personally though—I know that the main reason most people even found me in the first place was because of one Muppet piece or another. It's a badge of honor to be part of this community. Plus, it is an extremely welcoming group to be part of.

I haven't spent enough time in the Muppet realm to really feel pigeonholed though. There are still some ideas kicking around that I would like to explore. But I do want to try to spread them out. Plus I like to think that if something appeals to a Muppet fan like me, it would appeal to other Muppet fans out there. It doesn't always pan out, but it's worth a shot. Ultimately, I do this just because I enjoy it. And if others enjoy it as well, it is just a welcome bonus.

Kevin Williams

I’ve never been one to really let myself feel pressured to do anything I didn’t want to. Nowadays I do leave sketches and napkin doodles’ around of Muley (my original character) with a Muppet or Peanuts character for attention. Even so, I’m surprised when someone finds my photos of napkin doodles online and says, “Woah, that was you? I took these home” or “I pinned them up in the kitchen of the restaurant.” It feels good. Though I wonder: would they have just kept Muley, or was his sketch kept because Oscar was on the napkin next to him? Looking back to when I would set up at conventions and festivals, I think one thing which hurt me was the decision to NOT draw or sell any other characters other than Muley the Mule and Friends. People asked if I would draw Peanuts, Muppets, Disney – anything other than Muley, but I would instead offer to draw Muley or his pals in those costumes. I felt it was important to my own self promotion to push my characters, not those which already had budget and promotion. Yet, I would see people flocking to booths where artists were selling their art of Batman and Scooby-Doo, Bugs Bunny and The Little Mermaid, and I would think, “Those aren’t even the actual artists or the real art. Why are they going there?” Stubbornly, I stuck only to my Mule. Many years now I’ve been out of the convention circuit. I look back and finally realized that people were buying those prints and visiting those artists because they enjoy the “retro memory” of the joy they felt watching or reading those characters, buying into familiarity rather than new, creator-owned properties. Looking back since I’ve been out of conventions the decision to stay away from other characters may have been a mistake. I could have used non–Muley characters to draw attention to my booth and thus more to Muley. If I could go back in time and do it all again I would add these other characters simply for the ‘draw.’ (Get it?)

Will Carroll

Often times it feels like all people wanna see from me and other artists is just one thing, over and over again. The most likes I usually get is my Muppet stuff, everything else gets very few likes as well. I draw what I wish and never think of the audience in mind.

Richard Gomez

I feel like this is an issue that follows all artists who gain popularity with a fan base. Usually I’m able to piggyback off of the Muppet wave with work that’s just Muppet inspired and more of the sort of thing that comes directly from my head…
But all my portraits of real people that aren’t connected to the Muppets almost always bomb. Sometimes, I don’t mind it. I know a lot of people are going to see my Muppet stuff, and only my close friends are going to see the sort of thing I make when I’m not thinking about the Muppets, and I like the intimacy that comes with that because virality is a little scary.

Final Thoughts

So to put a cap on all of this, there are three key things to remember here:

A fan artist is not solely defined by their fandom but being recognized specifically as one is not the worst thing in the world. For starters, the Muppets are a fantastic fandom to be associated with. Heck, it’s even landed me and so many others good freelance work!
If there’s a complaint, it’s that trying to come up with new ideas can be trying, but then again; what is a true artist without a challenge?
Finally, if you really dig what someone does and you found them through your shared fandom, be a pal and subvert the algorithms expectations by seeking out their other work and double–tapping that screen!

Just like you should with all the incredible artists who contributed today! Man, what a treat to get so many fantastic and talented people to not only share their thoughts but some excellent art too! I can’t stress enough how great these artists are, I respect each of them so much. Please be sure to check all of them out and again, thanks so much to: